Protecting Those Who Serve: Why Every Church Board Needs D&O Insurance
Churches play a vital role in strengthening their communities by guiding, serving, and inspiring those around them. Behind every thriving congregation are dedicated board members and volunteers who help shape their church's future. Yet many of these faithful leaders don't realize that their personal finances could be on the line if something goes wrong.
That's where Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance comes in. This coverage is designed specifically for the individuals who make important decisions on behalf of the church, typically pastors, elders, trustees, and officers. If a legal issue arises from one of those decisions, D&O insurance helps protect your leaders from personal financial loss so they can focus on serving rather than worrying.
What D&O Insurance Actually Covers
Most churches already carry property and general liability insurance, but D&O coverage is different. It doesn't protect buildings, vehicles, or equipment. Instead, it protects people.
D&O insurance helps protect the wallets and personal assets of a church board if they're personally named in a lawsuit connected to their leadership decisions. Common examples include:
- Financial missteps or questions on how donations or funds are used
- Employment issues, such as hiring or firing disputes
- Building or renovation decisions that lead to disagreements
Without D&O insurance, defense costs, settlements, and court fees could fall directly on the individuals serving on your board. It's important to note that D&O insurance does not cover intentional misconduct, fraud, or criminal acts. Still, for good-faith decisions made in service to the church, it's essential protection. It's a way to protect the people who lead, teach, and guide the church's mission.
When Good Intentions Lead to Hard Lessons
To see how this plays out in real life, consider this example:
A church raised funds to build a new facility. Later, the board discovered that purchasing and renovating an existing building nearby would save the congregation more than $1 million. After prayerful discussion, they decided to buy and remodel the older property, a choice that made the most financial sense.
However, several donors disagreed. They believed their gifts were meant only for new construction and sued the board members personally for mismanaging funds. Even though the board acted in good faith, they still had to hire attorneys, attend court hearings, and spend countless hours dealing with a lawsuit that D&O insurance would have covered. The total donation amount from the donors who sued was $6,000.
This is only one story, but it's far from unique. Many church boards across the country have faced similar legal and financial challenges, and a simple online search shows just how common these situations have become.
Why It Matters for Every Church
Most churches operate on faith, trust, and good intentions, but even the best decisions can be misunderstood. Legal challenges can arise from something as simple as a budgeting choice, a staffing change, or a disagreement over how donations are spent.
When that happens, it's often not the church as an organization that's named in the lawsuit. It's the individuals who serve on the board. Without D&O insurance, those volunteers could be personally responsible for expensive legal fees or settlements. That means their savings, homes, or retirement funds could be at risk.
Adding D&O insurance to your existing policies is often straightforward and affordable. It can usually be built into your existing policy and customized to fit your church's structure and needs. Many carriers also offer options that include Employment Practices Liability (EPL) coverage, which protects against employment-related claims.
To put it in context, D&O coverage works alongside your other policies—like general liability, property, and workers' compensation—to create a well-rounded safety net for your church. Each plays a distinct role in protecting both people and property.
When considering coverage, talk with a trusted insurance professional who understands church operations. Every carrier's policy wording and limits vary, so it's wise to review how each aligns with your governance structure and risk profile.
With D&O coverage in place, your leaders can serve confidently, knowing that one disagreement or misunderstanding won't jeopardize their financial future or the ministry they love.
Ministry Takeaways
With the right protections in place, your leaders can serve confidently, and your church can stay focused on its mission. Review your policies annually, confirm what's covered and excluded, and document board decisions with care.
Before your next board meeting:
- Confirm whether D&O is in force and at what limit.
- Note the key exclusions (e.g., intentional misconduct).
- Clarify how D&O interacts with general liability and EPL.
- Schedule an annual governance risk review.
About the Author
